Medicare,
Life Insurance
& Annuities
Cookeville, TN

Serving the State of Tennessee for your Senior Insurance Needs

Certified Senior Advisor CSA credential — Scotty Lewis
AMDA credential — Scotty Lewis
★★★★★
5.0 · 63 Reviews

Scotty Lewis is a Cookeville-based independent insurance agent serving clients across all 95 Tennessee counties. He holds two credentials that most agents in Tennessee don’t: Registered Social Security Analyst (RSSA) and Certified Senior Advisor (CSA). That combination means one conversation can cover your Medicare options, your Social Security filing strategy, your life insurance, and your retirement income plan. No referrals to other offices. No starting over with someone who doesn’t know your situation.

The Upper Cumberland region is where Scotty built his practice — Cookeville, Crossville, Sparta, Livingston, and the counties surrounding them. But phone and video consultations mean clients from Memphis to Mountain City get the same service. If you’re a Tennessee senior sorting out Medicare or retirement coverage, this office can help.

Upper Cumberland region Tennessee

Upper Cumberland Life & Health works with numerous highly rated carriers, so the plan recommendations you get are based on your needs and your budget. There’s no cost to you for this service.

Services We Offer

We work with Tennessee seniors and families across a full range of insurance and planning products. Each service page goes deeper, but here’s what we cover:

  • Medicare Plans — Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement (Medigap), and Part D prescription drug plans. If you’re turning 65 or switching plans, we’ll walk through your options side by side.
  • Life Insurance — Term, whole life, final expense, and indexed universal life. We match coverage to your income replacement needs and your family’s situation.
  • Annuities — Fixed and fixed-indexed annuities for guaranteed retirement income. We explain exactly how they work, including surrender periods and fees, before you sign anything.
  • Social Security Planning — As a Registered Social Security Analyst, Scotty runs the breakeven math on filing ages, reviews spousal and survivor benefit options, and coordinates your Social Security timing with your Medicare enrollment.
  • Dental, Vision & Ancillary Plans — Stand-alone dental and vision coverage, hospital indemnity, and cancer/critical illness plans to fill gaps that Medicare doesn’t cover.

Tennessee countryside

Why Choose Upper Cumberland Life & Health

There are a lot of insurance agents in Tennessee. Here’s what sets this practice apart.

  • The RSSA credential is rare. Scotty is one of a small number of agents in Tennessee who holds the Registered Social Security Analyst designation. That credential requires formal coursework in Social Security rules, filing strategies, and benefit optimization. You won’t find it at most insurance agencies, and it changes the quality of the conversation. Filing at 62 versus 67 versus 70 produces very different lifetime totals. Spousal and survivor benefits add another layer of complexity. Those decisions are worth getting right the first time.
  • Independent means unbiased. We’re not captive to any single carrier. We can quote Medicare Advantage plans, Medicare Supplement plans, and Part D drug plans from multiple companies and show you the comparison in plain language. You pick the one that fits. We don’t push a preferred product. We don’t have a quota to hit for a specific insurance company.
  • Local, but statewide. The office is in Cookeville, Tennessee, at the heart of the Upper Cumberland region. We make house calls for clients who prefer it. And we serve clients in all 95 Tennessee counties, in person, by phone or Zoom.
  • No cost to you. Our compensation comes from the carriers, not from your pocket. The consultation, the plan comparison, the enrollment help — all of it is free to you. That’s how independent Medicare brokers work.

Who We Serve

Most of our clients are in one of four situations:

  • Turning 65 and starting Medicare. The enrollment windows are strict and the penalties for missing them are permanent. Part B late enrollment penalties follow you for life. We walk through your options, confirm your enrollment window, and make sure the paperwork is submitted correctly and on time.
  • Already on Medicare and reviewing coverage. Plan benefits change every year. Annual Enrollment Period (October 15 through December 7) is the time to compare what you have against what’s available. Premiums, formularies, and network doctors all shift. A plan that was right last year may not be the best fit now.
  • Planning retirement income. Clients who want to coordinate when to claim Social Security, how to fund retirement with an annuity, and how to keep Medicare premiums from jumping due to IRMAA surcharges. These three decisions affect each other, and we cover all three.
  • Families managing coverage for a senior parent. We work with adult children who are helping a parent navigate Medicare, final expense insurance, or long-term care planning. That often means a three-way call or a home visit. We make it work.


We serve clients in Nashville, Knoxville, Memphis, Chattanooga, and everywhere in between, including rural counties across Middle and East Tennessee where options can be limited and guidance is hard to find.

Middle Tennessee rural landscape

Frequently Asked Questions

Are you an independent agent, or do you represent one company?

Independent. We work with multiple carriers and have no obligation to place you with any particular one. Our job is to find the plan that fits your needs and your budget, not to hit a sales quota for a specific company.

Do you serve clients outside of Cookeville?

Yes. We serve clients across all 95 Tennessee counties. Some clients come to our Cookeville office at 1435 S Jefferson Ave. Others prefer a home visit, phone consultation or Zoom video review session. We accommodate all three. Distance is not a barrier.

What is an RSSA, and why does it matter?

RSSA stands for Registered Social Security Analyst. It’s a professional designation that requires formal training in Social Security rules, claiming strategies, spousal and survivor benefit options, and coordination with Medicare. Most insurance agents don’t hold it. It matters because Social Security filing decisions are permanent, and the difference between a well-timed claim and a poorly timed one can add up to tens of thousands of dollars over a retirement. Having that conversation with someone who has done the coursework is different from guessing at it.

How much does it cost to work with you?

Nothing. Our compensation comes from the insurance carriers when you enroll in a plan. The consultation, the plan comparison, and the enrollment assistance are all provided at no charge to you. That is standard practice for independent Medicare brokers in Tennessee.

When is the right time to call?

The best time is three to six months before you turn 65, so you’re not rushing enrollment decisions. If you’re already on Medicare and haven’t compared your plan in a few years, Annual Enrollment Period (October 15 through December 7) is when you can switch. And if you’ve recently retired, changed your income situation, or lost employer coverage, those are all trigger events worth a conversation. There’s no wrong time to ask.

Call the Cookeville office at 931.316.1182, or use the form below to set up a free consultation. We’ll cover your Medicare options, your Social Security questions, or both. There’s no obligation and no pressure.

Get a Free Consultation

What we're offering

Our Services

Medicare

Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement (Medigap) and Part D drug plans, explained in plain language. We help you compare the options available to you and keep your coverage current each year.

Life Insurance

Term and whole life coverage that can replace income, pay off a mortgage or leave something for your family. We help you work out how much coverage fits your situation.

Final Expense Insurance

Generate Your Free Final Expense Quote Online Today!

Registered Social Security Analyst

Scotty is a Registered Social Security Analyst (RSSA). He can walk you through when to claim Social Security and how that choice fits with the rest of your retirement plan.

Ancillary Products

Supplemental plans such as dental, vision and hospital indemnity that help with costs Medicare and other health coverage leave open.

Annuities

Annuities are insurance contracts that can turn savings into a steady income stream in retirement. We explain how the main types work and what they cost, so you can decide whether one fits.

UCLH Insurance

Free Final Expense Quote Generator

Testimonial

Read Our Recent Success Stories!

5.0
Based on 63 reviews
Mike LY
October 2026

Received excellent service along with an understanding acknowledgment into what I was wanting help with.

Gayla Nikkel
October 2026

We appreciate Scotty's professionalism, friendly demeanor and helpfulness as we enter into our retirement lifestyle.

Lou Bigden
October 2026

Very pleasant and knowledgeable in what he does.

Laura Zelm
October 2026

Scotty is very nice and knowledgeable of what he is doing with the insurance. He helps you to get the best service of all

Sherry Brown
October 2026

Always does the best he can at saving me money with same coverage

Terry Smith
October 2026

Wonderful a great guy to do business with

Holly Rock ranch
October 2026

Scotty Lewis has done a good job helping me with all my insurance needs. For the past 5 years he has worked with me to make sure I have the best coverage he is always a pleasure. Thank you Scotty

Cheryl Steinmetz
October 2026

Reviewed several options... Found and arranged a great plan for me. Communication was on point. THANKS

dmr122003
September 2026

I was helped out a lot ..not knowing much about insurance , I was guided in the right direction for my needs . I recommend at least talking with them , they followed up to make sure my needs are still being met ..

Debra Fancher
September 2026

Scotty is so conscientious. He checks back with me every year to make sure that my plan is still a 100% relevant for my needs. He's very meticulous and knowledgeable with all the upcoming changes that are taking place in all the different plans.

Amy Farley
September 2026

Scotty has always been there for me with answering my questions. Also If for some reason he doesn't know it, he will quickly find it for you. Also so nice to work with.

Scott Nydegger
September 2026

Friendly, knowledgable that has time to steer You in the best direction for Your healthcare needs! Thanks Scotty!

Stan Pearcy
September 2026

Scott is so helpful & personable!

Annette Nydegger
September 2026

Scotty is the BEST out there! He made my transition to Medicare smooth n easy! He took the time to explain traditional Medicare, as well as the Advantage plans to me. What a blessing he is! Great to have someone so professional n knowledgeable to help navigate my healthcare,

Brian m Mouer
September 2026

Working with Scottie is always a pleasure and an educational experience. I always walk away with so much new information.

RANDY JOHNSON
September 2026

WOW, SCOTTIE IS THE BEST. HE IS VERY SMART AND HELPFUL AND ALWAYS FOLLOWS THROUGH ON WHAT HE DOES. I WOULD HIGHLY RECOMMEND HIM AND HIS SERVICES. 5 STARS!!!!

Cindy Martin
September 2026

Scotty is a great guy. I'm so very glad to have him as my agent.

Sarah Wilson
September 2026

Scotty Lewis is professional in all he does for his clients. He tries to get the best coverage for each person according to their needs.

Claud jones
September 2026

Scotty Lewis went above and beyond getting the right plan for mine and my wife's needs. He took the time to explain everything in great detail as to what was covered. We felt comfortable and was made to feel at home as soon as we stepped in the door. We are both very pleased with our plans , and appreciate him for pro…

ron kyner
September 2026

Scotty is great to do business with and easy

Starlet Folck
September 2026

Scotty and his wife are very caring people. Scotty will search for the best policy for you and then follow up with you to make sure you’re happy. He is the best!

LINDA ESTRADA
September 2026

I have used Upper Cumberland Life & Health for the past 4 years and even recommended Scotty to several of my friends. Scotty calls every so often to see how we're doing and keeping us updated on any changes coming in. I recommended Upper Cumberland Life & Health highly.

Debbie Hartman
September 2026

My guy Scotty has been very helpful and has gone out of his way to help me with this confusing process.

Gary Melton
September 2026

All I can say Scottie goes out of his way to help someone. And he's a good man

Janet Erskine
September 2026

Scott is very professional and easy to talk to about all my insurance needs. He explains things in a way I can understand. I really appreciate him.

Call Scotty Lewis: (931) 316-1182